California Privacy Agency Imposes $5.6 Million in Fines for Website Tracking and Opt-Out Violations – Including Joint Enforcement with Minnesota AG

The California Privacy Protection Agency (CalPrivacy) continues to aggressively enforce the California Consumer Privacy Act (CCPA), announcing four recent enforcement actions resulting in more than $5.6 million in fines. The actions against FedEx, Hertz, Polaris, and Filson focus on the use of online tracking technologies, failures to honor consumer opt-out requests, and privacy portals that did not function as intended.

Minnesota also announced a separate $150,000 settlement with Polaris arising from a joint investigation with CalPrivacy, bringing the combined total to more than $5.8 million. The coordinated enforcement action highlights the growing importance of complying with state privacy laws nationwide.

Numerous other states (including MN) have enacted comprehensive consumer privacy laws with similar requirements concerning targeted advertising, consumer opt-outs, and privacy request procedures. For automobile dealerships nationwide, these settlements provide important guidance on how regulators may evaluate website tracking technologies and privacy compliance practices.

The bottom line for dealers is that it is critical that you have a compliant privacy policy, and a properly functioning cookie banner that are accurately tied into a compliant DSAR portal. All the pieces of your privacy compliance program must work together properly to avoid the attention of the regulators – in California and beyond.

Online Tracking Technologies Can Constitute Sharing

One of the central issues in these enforcement actions was cookie banners, privacy policies, and the use of tracking technologies on websites that collected consumers’ personal information and made it available to third-party advertising companies.

In the FedEx case, which resulted in a $2.975 million fine, the company disclosed in its privacy policy that it did not sell or share personal information. However, CalPrivacy found that tracking technologies on its website transmitted personal information to advertising companies for targeted advertising. Under the CCPA, sharing personal information for cross-context behavioral advertising is regulated even when the business receives no payment for the information. Other state privacy laws regulate similar exchanges for targeted advertising as the sale of personal information, although specific definitions and requirements vary.

Dealers using advertising pixels, retargeting technologies, and similar tools should ensure that their privacy policies accurately disclose these activities and provide consumers with the applicable opt-out rights.

Consumer Opt-Outs Must Actually Stop Tracking

All four enforcement actions involved failures to properly honor opt-out preference signals, such as Global Privacy Control (GPC). GPC allows consumers to automatically communicate their preference not to have their personal information sold or shared through their browser. California is not alone in requiring businesses to honor these signals. States including Colorado, Connecticut, Oregon, Minnesota, and Maryland have adopted similar universal opt-out requirements for covered businesses; and all of these states are part of a consortium with California to enforce this requirement.

In the Hertz case, CalPrivacy found that the company’s website continued sharing personal information with advertising companies, despite consumers’ GPC signals. CalPrivacy also found that Hertz’s privacy policy failed to explain how these signals were processed.

The Filson enforcement action is also notable because the company used both browser-based and server-side technologies to share personal information. CalPrivacy found that neither method properly honored GPC requests. The agency also emphasized that each subsequent disclosure to a different advertising company could constitute a separate violation, potentially multiplying penalties.

Dealers should ensure that opt-out preferences are honored across all applicable tracking technologies, including those operating through third-party vendors or server-side integrations. Simply recognizing a GPC signal is insufficient if the website continues sharing personal information in violation of that request.

NOTE: These requirements to honor GPC signals will become increasingly important. Beginning January 1, 2027, California’s Opt Me Out Act will require businesses that develop or maintain web browsers to include functionality allowing consumers to send opt-out preference signals. As these signals become more widely available, dealers can expect to encounter them more frequently.

Cookie Banners and Privacy Portals Must Function Properly

The enforcement actions also highlight the importance of ensuring that cookie banners and privacy preference tools actually implement consumers’ choices. In the Hertz case, which resulted in a $1.55 million fine, the cookie preference windows on its Dollar and Thrifty websites initially displayed advertising cookies as disabled. However, if consumers closed the window using the “X” without clicking “Save Changes,” the settings reverted to allowing advertising cookies. CalPrivacy found that this confusing design required an additional, non-obvious step for consumers to exercise their opt-out rights.

Similarly, Polaris, which received a $910,986 fine, offered a “Decline All” button in its privacy preference window. Nevertheless, CalPrivacy found that clicking this button did not stop all advertising tracking. In one instance, clicking “Decline All” actually triggered a Meta tracking pixel that shared personal information with Meta.

FedEx experienced a similar issue, with certain tracking technologies continuing to share information even after consumers disabled tracking cookies through its cookie preference tool.

These findings reinforce the requirement that dealerships cannot rely solely on the appearance of a compliant cookie banner. The underlying technologies must be properly configured so that consumer choices are accurately implemented.

Privacy Requests Must Be Easy to Submit and Process

The cases also addressed problems with consumer privacy request portals and other methods for exercising privacy rights. Polaris required consumers submitting opt-out requests to complete an additional email verification step before processing their requests. Both California and Minnesota regulators challenged this practice because, unlike certain other consumer privacy rights, requests to opt out of sale or targeted advertising generally cannot be conditioned on identity verification.

Filson, which received a $217,987 fine, had even more fundamental problems. Its privacy policy directed consumers to a telephone number, email address, and webpage to exercise their rights. However, some telephone inquiries and emails went unanswered, while the webpage link led to an error page. Its privacy policy also directed consumers to a “Your Privacy Choices” link that did not exist on its website.

FedEx similarly maintained an online privacy request form that expressly excluded tracking technologies, directing consumers instead to a separate cookie preference tool that did not fully stop sharing.

These findings emphasize that privacy portals, links, and request procedures must be accessible, functional, and capable of processing the rights consumers seek to exercise. Businesses must also ensure that employees responsible for handling privacy requests are properly trained.

Minnesota Joins California in Coordinated Privacy Enforcement

The California and Minnesota Polaris actions arose from a joint investigation conducted through the Consortium of Privacy Regulators, a bipartisan group established in 2025 to coordinate privacy enforcement efforts across states.

The Polaris action is the first enforcement action announced by the Minnesota Attorney General under the Minnesota Consumer Data Privacy Act (MCDPA), which took effect July 31, 2025. In addition to the $910,986 California fine, Polaris agreed to pay Minnesota $150,000 to resolve allegations involving failures to honor GPC signals, improper verification requirements for opt-out requests, and inadequate privacy disclosures. Minnesota also alleged that Polaris had failed to conduct and document required privacy assessments for its processing of personal information for sale and targeted advertising. The Minnesota settlement also requires Polaris to establish an approval process for new tracking technologies and train employees responsible for privacy requests.

The coordinated action demonstrates that privacy enforcement is no longer confined to individual states. The Consortium of Privacy Regulators now includes a dozen state privacy regulators that share information and coordinate investigations and enforcement efforts. Businesses operating across multiple states could therefore face simultaneous enforcement actions under different state privacy laws for the same underlying practices.

Quarterly Testing and Independent Verification of Privacy Tools

The settlements also emphasize the importance of regularly testing website tracking technologies and privacy management tools, rather than relying solely on vendors’ assurances.

All four California settlements require some form of quarterly review or testing. Hertz and FedEx must test their tracking configurations at least quarterly and whenever new tracking technologies are added, while Polaris and Filson must conduct quarterly reviews of their tracking technologies to ensure consumer opt-outs are properly honored. The separate Minnesota settlement with Polaris similarly requires quarterly audits of its tracking technologies for three years.

The Hertz settlement provides particularly detailed guidance. It requires testing in both staging and live website environments, across different browsers, mobile platforms, and tag management systems. Testing must cover both client-side and server-side tracking technologies, known and unknown consumers, and different opt-out scenarios, including GPC signals, cookie banner selections, and first-time visitors. These tests must examine website behavior before and after consumers opt out to determine whether tracking and data sharing actually stop.

Importantly, the Hertz settlement goes a step further. The agreement specifically prohibits Hertz from relying solely on representations from its consent management platform or other service providers. Instead, Hertz must independently assess, at least twice annually, whether those providers are properly processing consumer requests, including whether they meet applicable deadlines and provide compliant methods for exercising privacy rights.

Although these testing obligations arise from the individual settlements rather than a universal statutory testing schedule, they provide useful guidance on what regulators consider meaningful verification. Simply installing a consent management platform and assuming it works is not sufficient.

Bottom Line for Dealers Nationwide

These enforcement actions illustrate that privacy compliance requires more than publishing a privacy policy or installing a cookie banner. Dealers must ensure that their privacy tools work as intended and that the tracking technologies operating on their websites actually honor consumer choices.

While California has been particularly active in enforcing these requirements, dealerships in other states should not overlook the broader implications. Many state privacy laws provide similar consumer rights, and regulators in other jurisdictions have increasingly focused on website tracking and opt-out compliance. Dealers should evaluate which laws apply to their operations, recognizing that requirements and exemptions differ by state.

Dealers should consider adopting a quarterly review process to verify that their cookie banners, tracking technologies, and privacy request portals function properly, including when new technologies are introduced. They should also independently verify that their consent management providers are properly implementing consumer choices rather than relying solely on vendor assurances.

ComplyAuto Can Help

ComplyAuto Privacy can help dealerships manage cookie preferences, support consumer privacy requests, assess website tracking technologies, and conduct periodic testing to verify that cookie banners function properly and consumer opt-outs are honored. Our tools have been tested across tens of thousands of websites and are designed to address all the requirements outlined in these actions and more. Contact us to learn more.

Scroll to Top